Thursday, April 22, 2010

MIT SDM Article - An MBA or an MIT Master’s in Engineering and Management?

I have just been covered in an article in the MIT SDM Website!

An MBA or an MIT Master’s in Engineering and Management?

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

An MBA or an MIT Master’s in Engineering and Management?

By Charles V. Atencio, SDM ‘09

Almost mid-way through my engineering consulting career, I found myself wondering whether to pursue an MBA or a Master’s in Engineering and Management.

I had gone into engineering design after graduating with a B.S. in Mechanical Engineering, working mainly on infrastructure for pharmaceutical enterprises. At first, it was interesting—you have to understand the needs of the stakeholders and the business ecosystem—but after a while I realized that you never really owned your product. You designed it; you oversaw the construction, and then you turned it over to someone else. You were part of facilities and part of the operational budget, not strategic and definitely not viewed as adding value to the enterprise – which was what R&D did. And when I met with clients and asked questions such as, “How does this product contribute to your overall business strategy?” they weren’t really interested in hearing from me. Such issues were never considered part of the scope of the engineering consultant. Not content with this state of affairs, I decided to broaden my horizons.

I briefly considered pursuing an MBA, but didn’t want something so rigorously focused on profit margin. There is more to an enterprise and its organization than financial statements. To me, MBA schools are commoditized and, generally speaking, they concentrate primarily on the bottom line.

I wanted to leverage the fact that I’m an engineer and a technophile and integrate that with business. Then I found the System Design and Management (SDM) program, which allowed me to remain an engineer and still ask the big picture business questions. SDM opened new career options for me by bringing forward latent talents and now, after a year-and-a-half in the program, I can see myself working in one of two areas: product management or change management.

The System Design and Management program has also provided opportunities to further develop my leadership abilities. I have had many opportunities to help make a difference in SDM and the greater MIT community.

A good example of this was when I helped establish an SDM mentoring program for the MIT undergraduate students in the Gordon Engineering Leadership program. Leadership does not only entail “getting things done”, but also enabling others to realize their own potential. This skills of managing and leading others is crucial for SDM grads as they move forward in their careers towards executive level positions.

In terms of product management, the System Design and Management program has taught me to understand not only the needs of the engineers and researchers developing a technical product, but also the needs of those in finance and marketing. Engineers typically don’t focus on business strategy, and businesses don’t understand technical development. As an SDM graduate, I can connect the two and create a synergy between technology and business strategy in which the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. This is one way that an SDM is able to go “beyond the MBA”.

In terms of change management I could, for example, help a company with its acquisitions. Acquired assets all have their own IT systems, business processes, and organizational structures and you just can’t say, “Here’s your new platform; here’s your new organization,” and expect to get the integration and alignment you need to be successful. You need to manage the change and in order to do this you need people who understand IT systems, the organization, and the political and financial implications of changing them. MIT’s System Design and Management program has prepared me to do this.

Hiring an MBA to do either of the above could be tricky. In both situations, it’s important to hire someone who is capable of keeping up with the pace of technological change, who can interact effectively with the different cultures and agendas within an organization, and who can articulate the business case to all. If you don’t hire someone with the “big picture perspective” and the technological experience that SDM grads have, your company might miss out on a new wave of customers and end up playing catch-up, which is not a good place to be in today’s economy.


  1. Nice article, thanks. You haven't touched on the subject of the alumni network/connection that most MBA programs seem to concentrate on. How does SDM fare in comparison? (e.g. are there any career fairs/networking events taking place around campus, opportunities for interdisciplinary courses, etc.).


  2. A very good article. A succinct description of what SDM is all about. And to anyone who has the same question as Tony does:
    We have formed an Alumni Relations Committee precisely for the purpose mentioned. The goal is to reach out to alumni and create platforms (not just social networking events) that brings alumni and current students together.
    The most exciting part is all of this is student driven and overseen by faculty & staff who are very supportive.

  3. Nice article about an MBA or an MIT Master’s in Engineering and Management. A lot of MBA programs listed here.

  4. I think the best program for most people is the one that opens the most doors for them and gets them the job that they want without drama.

    The reason I say 'most people' is that most people get educated primarily to get jobs and feed themselves and their family. Everything else is secondary.

  5. i learn so many things from this blog.keep updating.thank you so much.

  6. The post is created in especially a not too bad way and it includes much profitable information for me. I am happy to find your perceived strategy for creating the post.This was a really uncommon test and in a perfect world I can go to the accompanying one. It was alot of fun and I genuinely had a great time.
    floor graphics new orleans

  7. extraordinary post, especially keen. I ask why another experts of the part genuinely never find this. You will longing to go on your making. I'm confident, you have a limitless perusers' establishment right now!
    ISO 23601

  8. I am John, how are you everybody? This article posted at this website is really good.

    Hosted PBX Singapore

  9. Exposition composing is essential today for an understudy. Today's training framework has requested of the understudies are to be great in English since English is essential for us. It has additional significance in each field of life.

    Buy perfect money

  10. Grateful to you.The critical of these affiliations is the acknowledgment association official renting on your before with all individuals who are to be cemented into the internment association. Case in point, the religious figure, office celebration organization home and the memorial park. Hi, its particular post concerning media print, we as a whole comprehend media is a fabulous wellspring of truths.

  11. Hurrah! At long last I got a site page from where I have the ability to truly gain huge truths as for my study and knowledge.Hello, the whole thing is going fine here and ofcourse every one is sharing data, that is in fact fine, keep up forming.

    Web Hosting Singapore

  12. I am really satisfied to peruse this site posts which conveys heaps of accommodating information, a debt of gratitude is in order for giving these sorts of measurements.
    Boekhouder zzp